Saturday, October 29, 2016

Life, Loss, Grief, and Blood Revenge: A Discussion of Jívaro Tsantsa Manufacture

Figure 1: Jívaro tsantsa, or shrunken head

Given the current Halloween season you may have seen several very interesting things, including images of bats, witches, goblins, and shrunken heads.  Many of these items actually have cultural significance in one way or another.  Today’s blog post is going to explore the realities of shrunken heads, which are an important part of the Jívaro culture.  This blog post will discuss who the Jívaro are, as well as their practice of creating tsantsas (Figure 1), which are popularly referred to as shrunken heads.

The Jívaro are an indigenous group that resides in the Amazonian rainforests of Ecuador and northern Peru.  They have lived in this region for generations, but they have been moderately studied over the years.  The reason for this is due to their perceived (and very real, in many cases) fierce some lifestyle that deterred many from reaching out and making contact with them.  The Jívaro were not without reason for being violent against those who came into contact with them, particularly as the Inca and Spanish Conquistadors had every intention of conquering and enslaving them. 

Ritual violence is a part of the Jívaro culture, but it is not the only aspect of their culture.  The term Jívaro actually refers to an amalgamation of at least five different indigenous groups who share various cultural traits.  These groups include the Jívaro (or Shuar), Achuara, Huambisa, Aguaruna, and Mayna.  They share common linguistic, economic, and political practices, which mean they speak the same language, are all horticulturalists, and have similarities in regards to how their societies are divided, maintained, and led. 

Of these five groups only the Jívaro frequently practice violent rituals, particularly those associated with head hunting and head shrinking.  There is a specific purpose to this ritual, however, as Jívaro believe that all individuals have a spirit, and that an individual’s spirit would bring about bad luck onto the living if the deceased’s death was not avenged.  The circumstances of the death were of little importance.  The expectation was that the living Jívaro were responsible for performing the blood revenge ritual to appease the spirit for the death of its living body.  This blood revenge also served the dual purpose of helping the living with coping with the death of a loved one, which follows in line with our modern understanding of the stages of grief, of which anger is one of those stages.  

Figure 2: Jívaro celebration after the creation of a tsantsa
  
Shortly after the death of a relative Jívaro males would congregate and go out on a hunt among other tribal groups (e.g. Achuara or Aguaruna) in search of a suitable candidate for the manufacture of a tsantsa, which is a shrunken head.  The ideal candidate was another unrelated male, particularly a warrior.  Warriors’ heads were sought after because it was believed that warriors had arutam, a magical personal power that increased based on the number of heads the warrior had acquired in his lifetime.  The arutam would be transferred from the head of the deceased to the warrior through the ritual of making the tsantsa.

Once a head was acquired (through killing and decapitating the victim) the male would return to his home village and begin the process of making the tsantsa.  First, the skin was removed from the skull (which was discarded), followed by sewing the eyes shut and driving pegs through the lips to keep them closed.  The flesh was then boiled in a pot of water for a specific amount of time.  Failure to maintain a perfect boil could lead to the head not shrinking or the hair falling out.  The head was immediately removed upon completion of the boil, but the process was not completed until after the head had fully dried out, which entailed putting hot coals or stones into the head to help keep its features and dry it out.  The pegs in the lips were replaced with cotton cords before the head was finally smoked to keep its shape and produce a leathery tsantsa.   The completion of the creation of a tsantsa led to a large celebration and ritual feasting, which was the most important aspect of the ritual.  The celebration and feast helped validate and reaffirm the male’s status as a warrior, as well as aided in coping with the grief associated with the deceased’s death that initiated the tsantsa process and creation (Figure 2).

The Jívaro no longer practice head hunting or tsantsa creation as it was outlawed in the early 20th century in part because demand by Europeans shifted the purpose of the ritual from assuaging individual and community grief to a murderous killing spree driven by monetary gains.  People can purchase replica tsantsas, which are most commonly made from sloths heads and are a suitable alternative to the real tsantsa as the Jívaro believe that they are descendants of the sloth.  It is important to note that the purchase of a real tsantsa is highly regulated today and in many circumstances is illegal. 

In conclusion, the Jívaro ritual associated with the tsantsa is one steeped in deep cultural roots and purpose.  To an outsider it may seem like a macabre practice, but it one that reaffirms the male identity and assists in dealing with the grief associated with the loss of a loved one.  While the Jívaro culture is different today from what it has been in the past they try to maintain much of their cultural heritage as much as possible, while existing in this modern, globalized world.   

Bibliography

Dhwty.  2014.  “The Shrunken Heads of the Jivaro.”  Ancient Origins.  http://www.ancient-origins.net/unexplained-phenomena/shrunken-heads-jivaro-001797

Garniewicz, R.  2016.  How to Shrink a Human Head.  San Diego Museum of Man.  http://www.museumofman.org/how-shrink-human-head/


Eveleth, R.  2013.  “How Does One Actually Shrink A Head?”  Smithsonian.com.  http://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/how-does-one-actually-shrink-a-head-5994665/?no-ist

Harner, M.J.  1984.  The Jivaro: People of the Sacred Waterfalls.  University of California Press: Berkley.
  
Krystek, L.  2011.  “The Head Shrinkers of South America.”  The Museum of UnNatural Mystery.  http://www.unmuseum.org/headshrinkers.htm

Lu, F., Fariss, B., Bilsborrow, R.  2009.  “Gendered Time Allocation of Indigenous Peoples in the Ecuadorian Amazon.”  Ethnology 48: 239-268.

Sauvageau, A, Kremer C, Brochu V, Julien F, Racette S.  2009.  Jivaro tsantsas or shrunken head: an expertise of authenticity evaluation.  American Journal of Forensic Medical Pathology 30: 72-74.


Steel, D.  1999.  “Trade Goods and Jivaro Warfare: The Shuar 1850-1957, and the Achuar,1940-1978.”  Ethnohistory 46: 745-776.
 

48 comments:

Unknown said...

There culture is somewhat backwards, how can you kill someone to help your people get over the person they lost? what about the persons you killed family and their people.

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

Terrance, it is important to remember to be culturally relativistic here. As discussed in class you do this by seeking understanding of the cultural tradition, although you do not have to agree with the action(s). If you have ever suffered a loss then you are probably familiar with the various and often conflicting emotions that are attached to that loss. Psychologists identify specific stages of grief, and one of those stages is anger. If you keep that in perspective you can understand why the Jivaro resorted to such violent acts to help deal with grief. This does not excuse their acts, but it should put it into perspective.

Unknown said...

knowing that today they make these out of sloth and sloth descendants does this cause them to be endangered?

Unknown said...

Is there a common mental problem that the groups that participate in spiritual possessions? Cause it seems crazy how they can experience those traits and be a mentally normal person.

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

While one species of sloth is currently endangered and one vulnerable (and all at risk) this practice is not identified as one of the causes of their endangerment/threatened status. This practice only occurs when a death occurs and only among select members of the group. Given that it was banned for a number of years it may not be practiced as frequently or to the same extent. I seem to recall reading a paper (when I was a freshman, like you) for one of my anthropology courses on this topic, but alas, I do not recall specific details regarding the frequency of the ritual.

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

Chukar, I believe you meant to post this on the possession post. Regarding your inquiry there isn't any information on consistent mental defects associated with individuals who are identified as possessed. Part of the problem with making such a assessment is that many people believed to be possessed are just social deviants that are doing something that society thinks is wrong but has no cognitive foundation (e.g. acting defiantly).

Aaliyah Caldwell said...

Entire blog was interesting, especially this "Once a head was acquired (through killing and decapitating the victim) the male would return to his home village and begin the process of making the tsantsa. First, the skin was removed from the skull (which was discarded), followed by sewing the eyes shut and driving pegs through the lips to keep them closed. The flesh was then boiled in a pot of water for a specific amount of time." it was creepy reading and picturing all of this

Meketa Clark said...

Wow, that was scary yet extremely interesting. I have have always enjoyed learning new things about different cultures and their customs. I wish it would have gave more info on who they killed to get the shrunken head. It said in the passage that people were afraid to go study them so I am interested in where the people came from and did they just kill the first person they came across?

Zachary Dickherber said...

I’m surprised that they went through all this so they can get stronger as to decapitate and shrink other warrior’s heads. I didn’t expect you to go into such detail on how to shrink a head too I wonder how we learned this method. Although this shows how the English was back then that they were able they to take this tribes tradition and a little of their culture just like that but I know I sound bad saying this but this practice is probably better left behind.

Anonymous said...

I found this blog very interesting because to know what they did in their culture. They ritual violence was not done purposely. the Ritual violence is a part of the Jívaro culture, but it is not the only aspect of their culture. The term Jívaro actually refers to five different indigenous groups. they all share various cultural traits. These groups are the Jívaro (or Shuar), Achuara, Huambisa, Aguaruna, and Mayna. These groups also share other thing as well such as; linguistic, economic, and political practices, which mean they speak the same language, and have similarities in regards to how their societies are divided, maintained, and led.
Ainya Lomax

Betsy Britt - Introduction to Anthropology SA-202 said...

If failure to boil the flesh correctly resulted in either the head not shrinking or the hair falling out, were the resulting heads not good enough and therefore discarded? What's more, this leads me to believe that being bald saved you from being a candidate for a possible tsantsa.

kelechi Anunobi said...

I believed this is a culture to be remembered since is a practice that occurs only on death.

Unknown said...

I find learning about and understanding the reasoning's behind what other cultures do fascinating. I had heard of head shrinking before but I now understand why they do it and do not find it as taboo as before.

D.Traywick said...

This Jivaro culture is very interesting. This is a prime example of the previous blog on Ethnocentrism and cultural relativism. The collecting of tsantsas practice is quite fascinating that they truly believe that decapitating strong enemies and preserving the heads brings luck. I guess a rabits' foot wasn't lucky enough

Anonymous said...

This article is interesting because in our culture we tend to grieve by remembering our loved ones and trying to bring as many people around us to uplift and comfort one another while in the Jivaro culture it is a form of grief to kill another man, to be culturally relativistic I see this culture as just having another way of grieving that may me odd to us but normal for them.
-Brandon Hall

Unknown said...

Like Delmar, I had heard of head shrinking before but never really understood it until reading this post. Now i find it rather interesting that they believe tsantsas bring them luck. In a way, it relates to our culture as well. So often, when someone is "bigger and stronger" than us, we as humans have this want or need to prove that we are in fact the "top dog" so to speak. We don't necessarily kill them and preserve their heads, but to an extent I get it. - Shannon

Roney Moore said...

This article was very interesting. The way the Jivaro go out head hunting and keeping the heads as a prize reminds me of how people in our culture would fight for a certain position of power at a job.

Unknown said...

This article is scary. It seem crazy to me how they removed the skin first and sew there eyes close . I never heard of head shirking before and the information was interesting. It's interesting learning about other people cultures and to know it wouldn't be acceptable here.

Anonymous said...

After reading the article I most say its very interesting and I kind of had an ethnocentric point of view when reading the article. It was due to some of the customs the tribe practiced such as head hunting but after I was done a reading the passage I was kind of understanding because every culture is one its own and that all cultures are different too.
- Arthur Holloway

Unknown said...

From an ethnocentric point of view this is a sick practice that i can honestly say made me want to stop reading this article how you can decapitate another human being and have pride in having his shrunken head with you for life is crazy.

Unknown said...

I always wanted to know where shrunken heads came from. I thought they were little doll heads not a real man's head.That is a horrible way to die.

Jeromia Riley said...

What happens to the heads after the celebration/ritual? Does the family of the deceased just keep it hanging somewhere in their home?

It's very interesting to see how different cultures deal with death.

Steven Benton said...

With the Jívaro no longer practice head hunting what do they do to substitute their actions after killing the people and carrying the shrunken heads around with them? Was these actions only towards the males or was there females that this happened to as well?

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

Good question, Mr. Riley. I know it was mentioned in one of the works I cited, but I cannot recall specifically where the head was kept. There were cultural rules attached to the treatment of the heads, though.

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

If the practice has not been completely abandoned they go with the default of sloth heads, and women were never chosen for their heads.

Unknown said...

So basically they can you kill someone to help their people get over the person they lost? What about the other person they killed? They have family too. That definitely is not okay.

Jaeda Lowe said...

I believed this is a culture to be remembered since is a practice that occurs only on death.

Unknown said...

I've learned what the term Jívaro means. It actually refers to an amalgamation of at least five different indigenous groups who share various cultural traits.

Unknown said...

Killing someone to help to help to people you care abut get over the death still happens today. If someone in a person's family get killed and they feel like it was injustice. Then someone in that family will want to kill the person that killed their family member. That's not right at all A death cant be justified by another death.

Anonymous said...

I am so glad they no longer practice the shrinking of heads. I do not understand the concept that decapitating then shrinking a head prevented bad luck. This is a culture I do not want to visit.

Logan Taylor

Seth Holyfield said...

To someone outside of the Jivaro culture, I'm sure this ritual seems horrific and inhumane. At the same time you have to remember that this is what these people were taught to do, and it has been in their culture for generations.

Anonymous said...

While this culture's practice, to me, is somewhat terrifying to say the least, I've heard of this before many years ago and I've seen many references to this practice before, including a scene out of the third Harry Potter. I never knew where they came from before, though, it's positively intriguing.

Mario Lucas said...

It is interesting to know that they included these rituals in there culture. Head shrinking and hunting sounds very bad and gruesome to ones body.

Unknown said...

I was always under the assumption that the head shrinking was just another Hollywood flare. When searching for a warrior, for the head shrinkage, would they battle the warrior first or have him be a sacrifice?

Anonymous said...

First of all the skin being removed from the skull was very disturbing because that is inhumane. This ritual is very different and is not something I personally would want to experience.
- Anthony Townsend

Apreshana Page said...

This post reminds me of another tribe that we went over earlier in the semester where they also removed heads to enter manhood if I recall it correctly.

-Apreshana Page

Justin Adams said...

This ritual is kind of creepy, a weirds me out a little bit. I do find it interesting that the people of this commnity believe in that there is magic stored in our head.

Anonymous said...

Article was interesting, especially the Jivaro culture their form of grief is to kill another man. I know that's totally the opposite of our culture a form of grief in our culture today is to cry but people also kill another person for grief also. Great blog!
-Micah Seals

Unknown said...

The only time I have heard of a shrunken head has been in movies, for example “Scooby Doo”. This does not give any history on the purpose or meaning of the object. After reading this blog it definitely gives it a different feel. It’s not just some creepy little head, it is actually an aggressive act. This threw me off guard. This seems like very extreme violence for a group, but this is how they felt they could defend themselves and protect themselves to show their strength. Very interesting to learn about!

Kahla Perry

Tonii Saffore said...

Reading about the head hunting literally felt like I was reading or gore horror story. The image of seeing the process of beheading the victim, piercing the lips together, boiling it, and than eating was all too real for me! I can't help but to wonder what it taste like, although I really can't image it being good, I feel like it has to have some taste to it. the reason I say this is because cannibalism wasn't an uncommon practice back in this time era. I even heard of some tribe leaving the brain of the deceased for the women and children to eat.

Taylor Morris said...

What Jivaro culture is different that what I'm use to but especially with killing the other man. Seems sort of like a sacrifice due to someone else's death before them but it works for them.

Unknown said...

Wow I’ve never been one to truly know the cultural significant within the Halloween’s season and the reasoning behind the fake shrunken heads. The witches , goblins Ana al forth. I never knew men hunt other men to get this “shrunken head” but my question would be , what made this a tradition? Cause the whole skimming of the head and seeing of the eyes is just gross .
-JaLyn Logan

Anonymous said...

I knew Halloween was not my favorite holiday but for the actual “shrunken head” to be an actual humans face is terrifying. Adding to this comment is was an “victim” which was innocent did not cause harm or a enemy to this cultural I imagined. If anyone is caught making a shrunken head in today’s time would they be punished federal or does there freedom of speech or their tradition for their cultural save them.
-Crystal Riley

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

Interesting question, Crystal. This practice is no longer practiced with human heads because it is illegal, so if someone were to do it they would be prosecuted accordingly.

Anonymous said...

Im sorry but this is disgusting. Having the guts to decapitate a human being and then turn around and keep a shrunken head?! You have to be kidding me.
-Kyla Thoams

Anonymous said...

This is interesting to see, humans doing this to humans was normal, now humans doing this to animals in not just one culture but many cultures is normal! Do you think europeans brought this to america? By putting the head of a deceased animal on the wall by showing your accomplishment for hunting and bravery?
Christopher McFadden

Anonymous said...

Reading this blog was a little scary for me. I can't imagine anyone getting their head cut off and then shrunken. I get why they do this because it's a part of their culture and they want to get rid of the bad spirits. I just feel like it isn't right for them to do that though. I do remember learning about it in this high school. It's very interesting to me how different cultures practice different things. I didn't know that the blood revenge also serves the dual purpose of helping the living with coping with the death of a loved one. I wonder does this still happens today?

AJ Moore

Anonymous said...

It was interesting to learn about the jivaro culture and their ritual violence. I never knew that the head shrinking had a specific purpose, to avenge the deceased death in order to stop bad luck from coming.

Elaine christopher