Saturday, October 22, 2016

Take On Me: A Cross-Cultural Comparison of Spirit Possession, Diseases, and Social Need



Today’s blog post is dedicated to a discussion of cross-cultural phenomenon of spirit possessions.  Spirit possessions are identified as changing individuals by a spirit entity or power who either strongly influences but most often takes over the individual’s soul, personality, and/or body.  Cultural groups from all over the world, particularly those in southeast Asia, Africa, and indigenous groups across the New World, have recorded instances of spirit possession that have and in many cases continue to occur today.  This blog post will discuss these cross cultural phenomenon of spirit possessions, the actual causes of these phenomenon, as well as the cultural explanations for their existence.

Spirit possessions are common cross-culturally, but they only occur in cultures that have an ideological belief in spirits or spirit-like creatures.  These entities go by a variety of names, such as djinns, demons, gheshi, and zar, just to name a few, and all are considered to have malicious intents.  In addition to ideological foundations, there also tends to a lack of understanding of health, disease, and mental illness (regardless of whether or not individuals have access to and/or been informed of the realities of these) among believers of spirit possessions.  Possessions are typically identified among individuals, particularly women, who act in abnormal or socially unacceptable ways.  For example, the Catholic Church identifies possessed individuals having superhuman strength, spitting, cursing, and practicing masturbation, while the Chuuk of Micronesia associate possession with violent shaking, wild activity, moaning and crying, screaming, and changes in voice pitch.  All of these behaviors are considered deviant in some way, which helps to identify them as being associated with spirit possession, but in reality these behaviors may be acts of deviance undertaken by the “possessed” or due to either a mental, emotional, or physical impairment.  Medical professionals recognize that most “possessed” individuals have a diagnosable (and sometimes treatable) illness, such as schizophrenia, autism, depression, seizures/epilepsy, etc. 

Spirit possessions have occurred historically as well as continue today.  Spirit possessions can occur in isolation or in waves.  Isolated incidents are common among individuals who are experiencing some sort of personal turmoil, whereas epidemics of spirit possessions tend occur when societies are experiencing economic, political, or social unrest.  In these ways spirit possessions act as “culture free-zones”, which free the possessed from cultural norms and allow possessed and those around him or her to cope with the situation leading to the identification of possession, be it a legitimate health concern or a personal incident.  It acts as a cultural time out, so to speak, to allow individuals to try to understand their personal and cultural circumstances.  This is not meant to downplay the severity of the situation, particularly in the event of disruptions to health, but it provides time and space for the individuals involved to cope with that which they do not understand.

Similarly to many other supernatural explanations of cultural phenomenon already discussed on the blog (e.g. vampires, dibbuks, witchcraft, etc.) the pattern of trying to understand the world seems to be a cultural universal, as well as evidence of our higher order thinking that distinguishes humans from other primates and animals.  While the choice of seeking a supernatural explanation for natural phenomenon may seem extreme it is actually quite common, particularly as turning to ideological convictions occurs among individuals who have a strong understanding of science.  

Bibliography


Cohen, E.  2008.  “What is Spirit Possession? Defining, Comparing, and Explaining Two Possession Forms.”  Ethnos 73: 1-25.




Jumreornvong, N.  2015.  “Exorcism & Mental Illness Across Different Cultures.”  Huntington’s Outreach Project for Education, at Stanford. 

Hezal, F.X. No Date.  “Spirit Possession in Chuuk: A Socio-Cultural Interpretation”  Micronesian Seminar.   

Mehraby, N.  2009.  “Possessed or Crazy?  Mental Illness Across Cultures.”  Interface: Considerations of Difference.   

No Author.  2016.  “Mediumship and Spirit Possession in a Cross-Cultural Context.”  Psi-Encyclopedia.    

Radford, B.  2013.  “Exorcism: Facts & Fiction About Demonic Possession.”  Live Science.  

Wedel, J.  2012.  “Involuntary Mass Spirit Possession Among the Miskitu.”  Anthropology & Medicine.  19: 303-314.