This
post
highlights the work required of my SA 202: Introduction to Anthropology
students. Students were given the
opportunity to explore a different culture through two lenses, cultural
relativism and ethnocentrism, and through this exercise learn about
themselves and the other culture. Several students were given the
opportunity to have their exemplary work
featured on the blog, and the students who provided permission have
their work featured here in this and the following blog posts. Please
show your
appreciation for their work through the comments.
By: Christopher Caslione
Ethnocentrism and cultural relativism both play an
active role in our daily lives. While one is instinctively closed-minded, the
other requires more of an effort to come from a place of understanding. In this
paper both of these terms will be discussed in greater detail. Ethnocentrism is
the “assumption that one’s own way of doing things is correct, while dismissing
other people’s views and practices as wrong or ignorant” (Welsch, Vivanco,
Fuentes, 2017). Cultural relativism
states that it is a “moral and intellectual principle that one should withhold
judgement about seemingly strange and exotic beliefs and practices” (Welsch,
Vivanco, Fuentes, 2017). For the purpose of this essay, ethnocentric and
cultural relativist views of the Kanamara Matsuri festival will be discussed.
Before we talk about both of these uniquely different ideas, we first need to
understand the history behind The Festival of the Steel Penis.
When an individual
from a different culture hears about this festival, they may become curious.
This is a festival about penises, after all.
Surely there has to be more to this than simply worshiping a phallic and
seemingly sexual body part. For the cultural relativist, there is a great
history that can be found surrounding this festival. It all began in Kawasaki,
Japan where it is said in Japanese folklore that there was a demon who fell
madly in love with a woman. This demon, who lived inside her vagina, became
jealous and bit the penis off of two men with whom she had sexual relations
with. To rid herself of the demon's curse, she married a blacksmith. This
blacksmith made the woman an iron phallus in order to break the demon’s teeth.
The plan was a success and the woman was no longer a slave to this jealous
demon. Because this worked, the phallus was made into a shrine to give thanks
to the spirits. The temple that held the shrine eventually became a place of
worship where people could pray for a happier married life as well as for the
gift of fertility. From the 17th to the 19th century, sex workers from brothels
throughout Japan would head to this shrine to pray to be protected from or to
rid themselves of STDs. The rise in popularity of praying for protection is
ultimately what gave life to this festival which “promotes sexual health”.
An ethnocentric view
of this festival for the non-native could be highly toxic. Discussing human
body parts can be uncomfortable enough for some, let alone parading around in
penis shaped attire and eating penis shaped food. Being a part of such a
festival could perhaps feel like a sin and cause absolute panic. This festival
is one that could open a lot of fear for the uncontrollably modest and highly
religious individual. This type of person may view the entire population of
Japan in absolute disgust after hearing or reading about this festival. This
type of closed-minded individual would not be open to hearing about the history
or even acknowledging the idea that talking openly about sexual health is
important. They are not wrong for how they view this festival. An ethnocentric
view can be important when it comes to protecting the individual. It can keep
someone out of trouble while also keeping up with family and cultural
traditions.
Cultural relativism is
something that is pretty important when it comes to a festival like this. In
American culture, talking about anything sexual can be uncomfortable and when
it is not discussed, people can get hurt. Hearing about this festival and
having the curiosity behind what this festival entails is something that can
help an individual grow. Existing in a manner that supports freedom of self
expression is something that can provide a lot of inner peace. Negative
judgment is based on fear and there is nothing serene about living a life of
fear-driven anguish.
A festival displaying giant penises everywhere is
undoubtedly something that may be a cause for feeling uneasy. Understanding
that this festival is not one based on perversion may help the ethnocentric.
When a previous student first heard of this festival, they couldn’t help but
express their unease. “That’s so disgusting!” This is a clear statement of
ethnocentric views and a misunderstood feeling of perversion towards this
special day. This individual could be used to a penis being seen as perverse
and may have a hard time seeing it any other way. Although I can understand
this reaction, it is a bit off putting to me. When I first heard about this
festival, I too thought that it was a tad perverted but because this seemed
unusual for Japanese culture, I wanted to understand what this was truly about.
For every ethnocentric view, there may be a cultural relativist one and this
festival is no different. "This
festival represents the values and history of Japanese culture.” Seeing the
value in something so taboo requires a great level of open-mindedness. This
student was able to practice cultural relativism with ease and be a voice of
reason and good health. After reading what this student wrote, I felt more
comfortable imagining myself being around such an individual. Sure this is a
different type of festival, but let us rejoice in their cultural choice and not
shame them.
Ethnocentrism and cultural relativism are both a part
of who we are and can even reveal our current level of spiritual fitness.
Assuming that “one’s own way of doing things is correct, while dismissing other
people’s views and practices as wrong and ignorant” (Welsch, Vivanco, Fuentes,
2017) is a dangerous and possibly lonely road to follow. On the other hand,
having a “moral and intellectual principle that one should withhold judgment
about seemingly strange and exotic beliefs and practices” (Welsch, Vivanco,
Fuentes, 2017) may afford great opportunities in life. Digging into the history
behind The Festival of the Steel Penis may create an opportunity for spiritual
growth, while shying away in fear might hinder this same growth. Either way,
each individual has the right to their own view.
Bibliography:
Welsch, R., Vivanco, L. and Fuentes, A., n.d. Anthropology: Asking Questions About Human
Origins, Diversity, and Culture. Oxford University Press:
Kageyama, Ben. “Japan's Steel Penis Festival.”
Medium, Lessons from History, 4 Jan.
2021, medium.com/lessons-from-history/japans-steel-penis-festival-a54a6ad35949.
Please go here to learn more about the Kanamara Matsuri festival.