Saturday, June 18, 2016

Baby Bust: A Review of Ancient Contraceptives



Women can be fertile up to forty years, and in that length of time many things can change.  These changes do affect a woman’s desire to get (or not) getting pregnant.  Emotional readiness, population control, financial stability, social/cultural preferences, health/medical well-being, and more are all reasons that affect a woman’s desire to carry a pregnancy to term.  The concern with preventing pregnancy is a long standing one that has existed for centuries, and it has not been until recently that pregnancy prevention has advanced to provide a safe outcome.  The failures of the past, however, are what have led to the successes of the present, and today’s blog post will discuss the past technologies for contraception. 

Figure 1: A Sea Sponge Pessary


One of the most common means of birth control is coitus interruptus, or more popularly known as the withdrawal method.  The earliest mention of this method is attributed to several sources, including the Biblical Old Testament, the Persian physician Muhammad ibn Zakariya al-Razi, and Master Tung-H’suan of ancient China.  Despite its poor results it continues to be advocated for today.  The Chinese and ancient Indians (of India) also advocated for a related technique known as coitus obstructus, which is a technique where men would put pressure on their testicles to stop sperm from entering the woman.  The ancient Egyptians, however, recognized a successful means of preventing pregnancy, which is the continuation of breast feeding.  This prevents ovulation and reduces the likelihood of the mother becoming pregnant again.

Vaginal suppositories and pessaries, devices meant to block the passage of sperm into the vagina, were also common in the past.  These took various forms, ranging from conservative to quite bizarre (by our modern standards).  African women were known to use plugs of chopped grass or cloth, Japanese women employed bamboo tissue paper, Middle Eastern, Slavic, and Greek women stuck simply to cloth, while Jews in the past utilized a sea sponge wrapped in silk (Figure 1).  Meanwhile, women in New Zealand women put rocks in their vaginal canal to prevent pregnancy.  More unconventional products used as pessaries included a mixture of crocodile dung, honey, and sodium carbonate (baking soda), which formed into a gum.  This was quite popular among ancient Egyptians.  Ancient Romans utilized a similar concoction, without the crocodile dung, when attempting to prevent pregnancy.  Pessaries eventually evolved to mixtures utilizing a variety of other chemicals, including potassium carbonate, ammonium chloride, coco butter, and quinine, some of which was used quite recently in the historical record as a means of preventing pregnancy.

Figure 2: Linen Condoms were commonplace among ancient Egyptians
Related to vaginal suppositories were condoms, which were common throughout history but not in the incarnation that they are known today.  The earliest recorded incidence of condom use was in 3000 BC and is associated with King Minos Crete who utilized goat bladders as a means of preventing exposure to venereal diseases.  Beginning at about 1000 BC ancient Egyptians began employing linen as a means of protecting themselves from venereal diseases (Figure 2).  Other sources claim that cave paintings and other historical documents make mention of condoms, although the connection to preventing pregnancy was not realized until recently.

Last but not least people believed that certain herbal remedies could prevent pregnancy and even in some cases cause infertility.  One of the most popular herbal remedies was silphium, a fennel plant that was indigenous to modern day Libya.  This plant was so highly promoted as having contraceptive properties that it was eventually made extinct due to overharvesting of the plant.  After this occurred, other herbal remedies were used, including rue, Artemisia, majoram, parsley, thyme, lavender, worm fern, and Queen Anne’s lace (Figure 3).  Dioscorides, a Roman physician, identified the following, when consumed, would lead to women being unable to conceive: white poplar and mule kidney, willow, asparagus, pepper, ivy, mint, and axe-weed.  Ancient Romans also believed that a drink concocted of hare’s stomach would lead to infertility, as well as wearing a cat’s liver would prevent conception.  

Figure 3: Queen Anne's Lace was believed to be a plant that prevented pregnancy
The lengths that people went to prevent pregnancy demonstrate a long history of a desire to control birth outcomes.  As ancient scholars rightly recognized at the time preventing pregnancy was safer than abortions, which were common when preventative methods failed.  Today we recognize the same exists today, but at least contraceptives used today, thanks to medical advances, have become more reliable and safer.

Bibliography

Davidson, E.R.W.  2012.  No Title.  Hektoen International: A Journal of Medical Humanities.  http://www.hektoeninternational.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=211&Itemid=627

Dowsing, S.  1999.  Contraception and Abortion in the Early Roman Empire: A Critical Examination of Ancient Sources and Modern Interpretations.  Master’s Thesis: University of Ottawa.

Evans, M.L. 2008.  “A Desire to Control: Contraception Throughout the Ages.”  Historia Medicinae.  1: 1-4.


London, K. 2016.  “The History of Birth Control.”  Yale-New Haven Teacher’s Institute.  http://www.yale.edu/ynhti/curriculum/units/1982/6/82.06.03.x.html

No Author.  No Date.  “13.2: Birth Control in Antiquity.”  http://www.uic.edu/classes/osci/osci590/13_2%20Birth%20Control%20in%20Antiquity.htm

31 comments:

Sarah Painter said...

I found this post so interesting. Call it me being naïve but I truly thought that birth control did not exist in earlier times especially as early as this post discusses. I made the assumption that there was a time when these things didn't exist that you just had as many kids as you were meant to have. I thought that sure there are people that cant conceive at all but the thought of birth controls never crossed my mind for a few reasons. 1 reason being I did think that back in the day families had lots of children for labor and 2 being that I had no idea these birth control measures existed or people even would think that way. Its amazing the remedies they came up with and I'm even more curious now as to how they found out wether or not these measures were effective.

Tamara Mazurie said...

Birth control what very controversial subject I can remember the method my parents had since my mom was a devote Catholic it was against her religion to take any type of birth control so I was conceived using the rhythm method. This is a form that revolves around a woman's cycle it was only about 40% effective so here I am.

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

Trial and error is how they found out, although we do know that certain remedies actually do work in specific ways. For example, arsenic is an effective means of prematurely ending a pregnancy, and there is a long history of use of arsenic throughout parts of Europe for this very purpose.

Anamari Mendez Jimenez said...

I remember accidentally learning about the ancient romans and silphiums in sixth grade but I did not realize the variety of different methods humans have tried over time. Although this post has enlightened me it has also confused me because I don't understand why birth control is so controversial. The human race has sought after a form of prevention for so long, yet the idea of birth control is still seen as morally wrong. It may be missing something, but I fail to see the logic behind the controversy or why the modern day pill isn't available over the counter.
Anamari Jimenez

Anonymous said...

I find this to be engrossing. I have always been curious on what women have used for contraception, as well as what they used during menstruation.
As Sara Painter mentioned above, how does one even come up with ideas like the goat bladder and crocodile dung. It also makes me wonder if such means caused any other issues like vaginal infection. It just goes to show that where there is a will, there is a way.
Sara Indiano

ChristieAquino said...

It's very interesting the length people went to prevent pregnancy. I can't imagine how it would feel to put rocks in the vaginal canal or crocodile dung. I didn't even know that people had some types of contraception so far back in the past. I figured that it was a modern thing. I would also like to know the health problems that occurred due to some of these methods.

Anonymous said...

this was interesting and gross at the same time. who came up with these remedies and ideas to prevent pregnancy? i cannot help but wonder if there were any issues with vaginas because people back in the days would just create something to prevent getting pregnant. even if it means inserting a rock in their vagina. Also, i didn't think people back then used or came up with these kinds of things. Weird, disgusting but creative.

Caylynn Lam Yuen
Anthropology 101
1st Summer Session 2016

Unknown said...

What an interesting post Dr. Boston. I always have been so interested in these types of topics that can be seen in today's societies. One fact that really made me wonder is the New Zealand women who put rocks in their vaginal canals to prevent pregnancies. What long term effects would that have on a woman? I feel there had to be healthier and not to mention safer ways to prevent pregnancies than putting a hard substance in your privates.

Cady Fine said...

I've always loved learning about this kind of history, especially since they weren't allowed to teach it in high school! After reading this post, it made me wonder how many infections these women got from sticking crocodile poop and rocks in their vaginal cavities. It also is upsetting because there are a lot more women options, and the males just had a few experimentations throughout history.

Charlie Goggin said...

I have great confidence in the cat liver method. I am fairly certain that a cat's liver worn by either my spouse or myself would most certainly prevent conception!

Charlie Goggin
:-D

Aaliyah Caldwell said...

I had no clue that the post birthh control was invited then, nor did i know the types they had. Woman used chopped grass and cloths, honey, tissue and more, that's strange and before reading this if I would of thought there was birth control I wouldn't have thought they used those things.

Zachary Dickherber said...

Wow I did not know that people would go to such lengths to prevent themselves from becoming pregnant even going as far to harvesting a plant to extinction.

Unknown said...

I never knew that people have done so much to not only prevent pregnancies but end them early. Its incredible the lengths people will go to not have kids.

D.Traywick said...

After reading this, It makes me wonder what was the first instance that made man say "hey I need to cover this before doing this." Was there early signs of infection they noticed that potentially made them want to cover while still enjoying the pleasuring feeling. Also, I also wonder with all the STD's out now and all the unplanned children, why people continue to practice coitus interruptus method with random people. Yes, with your significant other but if you don't use protection of some sort you're asking to eventually have a child because pre-cum is very potent opposed to popular belief.

Unknown said...

This post came off as funny to me because being a boy growing up you continuously here "don't get nobody pregnant" or " you better not bring no babies home". Its actually comical to know that you're not the only one getting "the talk" or that it didnt just start.

Anonymous said...

After reading this, I didn't know that birth control existed in ancient times. In reading this I found some of the methods that they used very strange and if women had to use these methods today that a majority wouldn't even think about doing these methods myself included. -Brianne Pickett

kelechi Anunobi said...

This is interesting, but i know that most men can not use withdrawal method because they found it difficult to do, and breast feeding can only work for those who have babies.

Miah White said...

I had no clue birth control existed that long either. I thought maybe 40 something years but that long!

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

Well, more effective and reliable birth control has existed for about 40 years or so. I would not recommend some of these options.

Unknown said...

its crazy how condoms was used so many years ago in 3000 BC. I thought that birth control was a new world thing.

Anonymous said...

I did not know that women could be fertile up to 40 years ! I think i missed it but what exactly is a A Sea Sponge Pessary and what does it do?

-Daisha Benton

Eugene Sainterling said...

I was shocked to find out that birth control was even used so long ago. It's crazy how in this day and age some people still can't get it right.

Daisha Townsend said...

Were those condoms uncomfortable?

Evanna Waller said...

It's interesting how things were inserted into the vagina to prevent pregnancy, but condoms were always for STDs until recently.

Mario Lucas said...

Seeing that women can be fertile and get pregnant for up to forty years is amazing. It is interesting to know that cultures had their own forms and remedies of birth control with plants and substances.

Unknown said...

How common were STDs among these times? I would assume due to poor medicialization that there were more stillborns and/or failed pregnancies than today as well.

Amber Barnes said...

I am surprised that birth control was even attempted a long time ago. It must have been extremely uncomfortable to have those things placed in you.

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

We know through paleopathological studies that STDs have a long history and were prevalent in the past. How prevalent is a matter we have not yet ascertained.

Anonymous said...

Ok this post was interesting and gave me the the shivers thinking about the weirder (to our standards) of Contraceptives, like the rocks and the glue made with crocodile dung. It is weird to hear that so many different cultures and people all over the world had Contraceptives or allowed them because I know religions ban them so that they exist within certain cultures is a shock to me. -Malachi Brewer

Monay P said...

Gosh, this is bind blowing for me. i didn't know birth control existed. Some of the tactics were crazy. I know this was uncomfortable.

Jasmine Busby said...

Queen Anne's Lace was probably worse than the birth control used today. I believe the birth controls we have today causes disease and cancers. Although I was fascinated when i read that birth control was attempted so long ago.
-Jasmine Busby