Saturday, January 30, 2016

Canine Connections: The Origins of Man’s Best Friend


Dogs are considered man’s best friend, and why shouldn’t they be?  They are loyal, playful, and helpful.  Dogs have been known to diagnose disease in the ill, flush out hidden drugs and bombs, as well as search and rescue humans trapped under various types of debris.  Humans and dogs have a very connected history that is very well understood today, but until recently it was unknown specifically how and when this history began.  Last year, however, the origins of the domestication of dogs was more precisely known based on a discovery in Siberia, adding another layer to the mystery of dog domestication.  Today’s blog post is going to discuss this new evidence, as well as other pieces of evidence related to the origins of dog domestication.

For many years archaeological and genetic evidence suggested that dogs were domesticated from wolves between 12,000 to 15,000 years ago.  Dogs were believed to have been domesticated at the advent of agriculture across the Old World (Europe, the Middle East, and Asia), but the exact location of dog domestication was unknown.  In 2015, though, the discovery of a Taimyr wolf bone in Siberia by Love Dalén and the subsequent analysis of the bone clarified the debate.  Mitochondrial and nuclear DNA analyses of this bone suggests that dogs originated from the Taimyr wolf, pushing the date of domestication back to 27,000 and 40,000 years ago, which is when humans were largely nomadic and relied on hunting and gathering.  Not only that but the Taimyr wolf also gave rise to modern day wolves prior to its extinction.   

While the date and time of dog domestication has been clarified it is remains unclear as to how exactly domestication occurred.  Some scholars believe that early canines were easily domesticated because humans and dogs share several social and behavioral characteristics in common.  It is believed because both species are social, pack like creatures that travel and thrive in groups the connection was bound to occur.  It is further believed that early dogs and humans hunted similar prey, and therefore they may have worked cooperatively to meet their nutritional needs.  As this behavior became patterned domestication may have coevolved and dogs and humans domesticated each other.  Another prevailing idea about the domestication of wolves into dogs is the notion that early humans merely took in orphaned pups and raised them as their personal as well as occupational companions.    

It is still too early to determine which of the above ideas is more likely as no new evidence has been released, but hopefully this new discovery and subsequent analyses of additional evidence will lead to further clarification regarding the domestication of dogs.  What is clear thus far is that it appears that dogs were the earliest domesticated animal species, and that selective breeding, or the intentional breeding for specific traits, has led to the various breeds of dog that we know of today and the behavioral traits that reinforce the notion that dogs truly are man’s best friend.

References Cited


Dunham, W.  2015.  "Dog Domestication Much Older Than Previously Known."  Scientific American.


Fessenden M. 2015.  "Humans May Have Domesticated Dogs Tens of Thousands of Years Earlier Than Thought."  Smithsonian Magazine.


Grimm D.  2015.  "Feature: Solving the Mystery of Dog Domestication."  Science Magazine.

No Author.  No Date.  "6. Evolution and Domestication of Wolves."  Kids Planet


Savolainen P.  2007.  "Domestication of Dogs."  In The Behavioral Biology of Dogs, edited by Jensen, P.  Science.

37 comments:

Anonymous said...

The question of the origin of the relationship between humans and domesticated dogs is one that has always fascinated me. How much of the early process of selection was intended, or simply the result of early humans unconsciously choosing traits that appealed to them, such as those that were more docile.

Of particular interest to me is the results of the farm-fox breeding programs that have taken place in Russia over the last 20 years. This has produced remarkable changes simply due to selecting desired temperaments.
http://www.nytimes.com/1999/03/30/science/new-breed-of-fox-as-tame-as-a-pussycat.html

Margaret "Charlie" Goggin said...

I have also found this subject to be fascinating. The physical changes based on selecting for "less afraid" in these foxes are dramatic to say the least.

It brings to mind anecdotes I have heard from farmers and ranchers dealing with cowlicks and white on faces and legs of cattle and horses. Many old ranchers claim to be able to tell the temperament of a cow or horse from the location of "cowlicks" on the animals head and white markings on its whole body.

It seems hair whorls can also signal possible problems with brain development in human babies, leading me to believe this might have some biological basis. (http://newborns.stanford.edu/PhotoGallery/HairWhorl1.html)

There is another article I read about hair whorls and left or right handedness.(http://genetics.org/content/165/1/269.full)

I think our long history with dogs is worthy of further exploration. This bond between our species is deeply entrenched in our shared history and close relationships. We have clearly changed dogs appearance, behavior and physiology (the ability to digest starch, for instance). I wonder, how our relationship with dogs has changed our species?
Margaret "Charlie" Goggin

Kevin Izykowski said...

Dogs are very cool animals and I like them better than cats. What surprised me is that I had no idea that dogs evolved from wolves. Some breeds of dogs such as German Shepherds and Pitbulls seems more aggressive than Labs or Golden Retrievers. So pretty much the evolutionary theory about humans evolving from primates can apply to dogs as well. Since there is evidence, evolution can possibly apply to any modern animal around the globe.

Christine Jackson said...

I had an idea that dogs may have came from wolves because the appearance is similar and it would be very odd if dogs came from primates. However wolves and primates probably did not get along very well all those years ago to today. It is very fascinating that dogs came from wolves, and I already knew that humans came from primates, and to see that a dog is truly a man's bestfriend through loyalty and obedience. To go through evolution from the beginning, primates and wolves hated each other to evolve into becoming best friends is intriguing.
I think our relationship with our dogs has greatly changed for many people that have anxiety problems or have suicidal thoughts or of the like. Those people that have dogs will be comforted by their pet to make them feel better for the day, Until the dog see's his or her owner in sadness or panic mode then the dog will try to be like a best friend by making their owner happy again.

Ryan F. said...

Interesting article and I like the content, but I have two questions:
1) How can we be sure that the Taimyr wolf was the canine species to give rise to domesticated dogs. If we only found part of a bone, yes we can determine its age but how do we use that to determine the history of domestication?
2) If dogs were domesticated sometime between 12,000 and 15,000 (or 27,000 to 40,000) years ago, then can that mean that, that was the rise to modern Homo sapien sapiens entered the picture. In your class, we learned that there was a numerous number of hominids, but it was unsure when our species (homo sapien sapien) finally emerged into the world. Could this be the first species smart enough to domesticate dogs similar like how we do today?
My thought is that if we found the Taimyr wolf bone in Siberia, then that could conclude that this intelligence could've come from the Denisovans species (they both were in Siberia, and the times lines are very close apart given that this wolf bone could be up to 40,000 years old and the denisovans lived near that time).

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

1) As noted in the post nucleur and mitochondrial DNA is the key piece of evidence that confirms the Taimyr wold as the parent species. :)

2) Modern Homo sapiens existed at that time, but you are right regarding potential lines of various human ancestors. The recent discovery of Homo naledi (post coming at the end of the month) may be the key piece of evidence that supports the idea of ancestral "braiding" (various hominid species interbreeding) vs. ancestral branching (one species slowly evolving into modern H. sapiens). :)

Kayley Phillips said...

I was really excited to read this article, as I had an idea that dogs had evolved from wolves, but I was shocked to see that it took place nearly 30,000 years ago, or at least new evidence shows it's likely. I'm curious as to how long it took for small breeds like pugs and terrier dogs to appear, or even what the first small breed looked like to humans. As other wild animals become domesticated over the years, I wonder what the new cool pet will be and how widespread it will become.

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

I'm glad this post sparked your interest, Kayley. You can actually find information out about the timelines for specific breeds, such as pugs, as many breeds are historically known. :)

Unknown said...

I love my dog, and I am beyond happy to have her in our family, but could you imagine to be the first person to domesticate these animals; something that would have been considered extremely dangerous and wild at the time? Putting your hand out to the wild wolves to show that you want to help feed them? The evolution of these amazing creatures fascinates me. The help they bring to people on so many levels is extraordinary, but I for one, would not want to be the person who had to find out that all of this was going to be possible. I think it would put my mind at ease to think that domestication did in fact come from early humans who took in orphaned or wounded animals and nurtured them into the amazing animals they are today. :)

Michelle Amos (ANTH 205)

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

Actually, wolves are not nearly as dangerous as we culturally perceive them to be. Dr. Meegan Gray of the TMCC Biology Department did an excellent presentation on them in her talk on the likelihood of werewolves existing for the Monsters Panel back in October. You can speak with her regarding specifics. I wouldn't recommend approaching any wild animal by any stretch (because believe it or not but white tail deer actually kill quite a few people annually), but wolves can be very docile around humans if they do not feel threatened.

Anonymous said...

Amazing that they were able to determine that wolves actually date back further just by the research that scientists found in the fossil. There are many species of wolf actually endangered today because of over hunting. One of them being the Grey Wolf. - Julia Hartley

Anonymous said...

I have always been an animal lover. Growing up our dogs have always been family and not just pets. It is amazing how they have discovered that dogs originated from the Taimyr wolf from bone that they found in Siberia. Along with being able to determine that dogs had been domesticated from 27,000 and 40,000 years ago. The idea that we can discover so much from bone is astounding to me. A family friend owns some land where he rescues animals such as wolfs. He helps care for them. He will get in the cages with the wolfs and has created a trust with his animals. I have always been so afraid of wolfs especially from how movies make them out to be.There are dangers and our family friend has scares to show for them however he gives so much love in caring for these wild animals.

Leslie Milton
Anthropology 101
Course 3001

T. Schultz said...

Thanks for this information. I always wondered about this topic, but I never really had the time to look into it. I remember reading a book to my daughter, I think it was called "The First Dog", and it was about a cave boy and a wolf he had found. Kind of the same notion as you wrote in the blog. As a dog person myself, no matter how they came to be our companions, I am very glad they are.

Unknown said...

I enjoyed reading this blog mostly because I could relate to it since I am a dog owner. It is so interesting to me how all breeds of dogs where derived from wolves! I have a pug at home and I can't imagine how that breed came from a wolf let alone what would urge someone to keep breeding that type of breed unless they just wanted constant humor in their lives. Haha

Katienaomi Camacho said...

The evolution of the monsters we have in our homes makes much more sense now because, they have that wild blood in them! I have always wondered how humans domesticated our the little creatures, though it is not clear... I find it sweet that back then dogs were being adopted by us humans; something we still do today with stray dogs that need a loving home. Overall, it is awesome to know that there is chance that my dog at home may have a line of Taymir wolf! He's part Husky and he can be such a handful sometimes! I just know I'll be a bit more understanding when I find a dead bird in my backyard haha. - Katienaomi Camacho

Katienaomi Camacho said...

The evolution of the monsters we have in our homes makes much more sense now because, they have that wild blood in them! I have always wondered how humans domesticated our the little creatures, though it is not clear... I find it sweet that back then dogs were being adopted by us humans; something we still do today with stray dogs that need a loving home. Overall, it is awesome to know that there is chance that my dog at home may have a line of Taymir wolf! He's part Husky and he can be such a handful sometimes! I just know I'll be a bit more understanding when I find a dead bird in my backyard haha. - Katienaomi Camacho

Katienaomi Camacho said...

The evolution of the monsters we have in our homes makes much more sense now because, they have that wild blood in them! I have always wondered how humans domesticated our the little creatures, though it is not clear... I find it sweet that back then dogs were being adopted by us humans; something we still do today with stray dogs that need a loving home. Overall, it is awesome to know that there is chance that my dog at home may have a line of Taymir wolf! He's part Husky and he can be such a handful sometimes! I just know I'll be a bit more understanding when I find a dead bird in my backyard haha.

Unknown said...

It is fun to read about all the theories of why dogs became domesticated by people, and the ideas of how they might have in turn domesticated us to some degree. I personally find one avenue appealing. That we took care of orphaned pups. There are certain phenotypic expressions in baby mammals that make them look "cute". Obviously the degree to which something is cute or not is a subjective term, but it is also an expression born out of our biological evolution. The cuteness of a baby is not just a nice coincidence, it is a symptom of biological evolution that to some degree promotes fitness. Quite possibly there is some similar structural makeup in that of a human babies face and a young pup.

Unknown said...

This was a really interesting article. I like the idea of older humans hunting with dogs and having a symbiotic relationship. We just fit in with each other. Can you do one on cats next? Thanks!

Unknown said...

So after all we have talked about with Neanderthals and early humans, how do you think that the early humans managed to capture the wolves, because I'm pretty sure that the wold is always gonna be faster than man? Did they find a way to get it into a corner and tie a makeshift rope around it's neck or did they somehow trap it in a cave?

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

It is actually on the docket as my best friend asked about it when he was reading the draft of this piece.

Dr. Christine Elisabeth Boston said...

They most likely took the most docile wolves as that would have been in their best interests. It is also hypothesized that they took in orphaned wolf pups and raised them and bred only those with the best traits.

Jessie Crivelli said...

I love dogs, so of course I had to read this post. One of my old friends grew up raising wolves, and it was always interesting to me to hear stories about their gentleness and companionship. I've often questioned how dogs came about to be domestic and considered man's best friend, so I am really happy this post was written! It's amazing to me to see the research being done on such a wonderful topic.

Unknown said...

I'm guessing that for the first few generations, they had to keep them in a very strong holding pit or to tie them up until they were hunting.

Juber Baires said...

I love dogs and I have Yorkie one. It is amazing to read about how dogs evolved from the wolf. In this days we have a lot of different kinds of dogs. I can imagine human and dogs working together hunting for food back in the days. That will be funny to try to survive looking for a prey but, two different species working together.

Zachary Dickherber said...

Wow 40,000 years ago I would have never guessed that in my life at most it would have been like 2000 years ago because we don't really hear about the history of war dogs are loyal pet dogs until recently at least I haven heard of it but with a single bone it changed the story by double the age we thought dogs were domesticated.

Anthony Anderson said...

Since early childhood I have always been raised around dogs. So this blog post attracted me just because of my interest in the species.i was glad to be able to put a time on when they were originally domesticated. I knew the purpose was due to hunting but now I see that them doing the same things was the reason they attracted each other. The way they traveled and were social with each other influenced their bond.

Unknown said...

My cousin has 8 dogs and im always at his house so his dogs are like my dogs and we have a great connection. But its crazy to know how far back in time that people domesticated dogs.

DeAndre Oliver said...

I love dogs and I agree that they are a mans bestfriend. I never knew that dogs came from wolves so that was something new this blog taught me. I also didn't know that dogs originated from Europe and the Middle East. One thing that did make me wonder was the name of my moms dog because its some type of England name.

Rickey Smith said...

I never thought that dogs were a by product of wolves. I always thought they were separate because they both demonstrate different traits. (teeth and fur)

D.Traywick said...

I can see how dogs and humans hunted together to catch a similar prey and I love the mind of dogs. They are smart, easy to love, yet aggressive and protective when need be. Dogs have not only been domesticated but trained above expectations being a vital part to law enforcement and finding guns, drugs, and rescue missions.

Anonymous said...

Brandon Allen

I agree dogs are a man bestfriend I grow up around dogs all my life. They are easy to train, friendly, and great protectors, you can almost do anything with them from hunting to playing catching. If your there only child ask for a dog you wont regret your decision.

Anonymous said...

Jovie Black
I like the fact that humans and dogs share this unbreakable bond, if you treat them right. knowing that humans and dogs hunted together, eating the same things shows the similarities in characteristics. Nice read !

Unknown said...

This is really cool because I thought humans just stated being dog lovers, I thought it was a new world thing. I also find it interesting that our ancestors didn't kill the wolves to eat them but in stead they kept them around to keep them company just like we do our dogs now.

Amber Barnes said...

It is amazing how much was placed in the domestication of dogs. I love dogs and no matter what they are all different.

Unknown said...

Interesting that’s dogs seemed to have been derived from the Taimyr Wolf. As well that 40,000 years ago is such a long time for the discovery in 2015 to be able to be correlated. To know there is true meaning behind “ dogs are a guys bestfriend” is interesting as I thought it was a new societal norms to refer to your dog as your “bestfriend.” I like dogs but not to the extinct of saying I have a bestfriend within gone.
-Jazlyn Logan

Anonymous said...

I personally am not the hugest fan of dogs due to issues with them as a child. I will say that domestication is more common than I thought and dogs shouldn't have to endure that at all. I didn't know dogs were this beneficial to society. I always thought about getting a smaller dog, but I am still unsure.

Mya Bursey